Compare · cigars
Cigars and cigarillos: two different amounts of time
A cigarillo is shorter and narrower than a cigar and takes minutes rather than an hour. Cigarillos are more often machine-made and premium cigars hand-rolled. Smoker’s Warehouse stocks both: cigarillos at the front counter and premium cigars in a walk-in, climate-controlled humidor.
Size, and what it costs you in time
Formally, a cigarillo is shorter and narrower than a cigar. In practice, the difference is time.
A cigarillo takes minutes. A full-size premium cigar takes most of an hour, depending on the vitola, and is not something you start and abandon. People who think they dislike cigars have often tried to fit one into a gap that was too short.
If you have twenty minutes, a cigarillo is the product built for twenty minutes.
How they are made, usually
Cigarillos are more often machine-made and premium cigars more often hand-rolled, with exceptions on both sides.
Machine-made product is consistent stick to stick, which suits something you buy by the pack. Hand-rolled product varies a little, which is part of what people pay for and part of why singles exist.
Where they live in our stores
The front counter is fast: cigarillos in packs and boxes. The walk-in humidor is a climate-controlled room with singles on the shelf, where you can read bands and take your time. You can do either on the same visit.
What each costs here
Machine-made cigarillos start around $0.99 on our shelf and premium cigars run to $75.00 at the box end, as of 31 October 2026, the same at both stores. The useful comparison is within a format, and every line on the cigar page shows its format.
If you have never smoked either
Ask at the counter, and say so. The question to answer first is how much time you want to spend. Singles are on our shelf for this: one stick is a cheaper way to find out than one box.
Nicotine is an addictive chemical. Cigars and cigarillos are 18+ with photo ID. Nothing here describes any product as safer than any other. If you are looking to quit, the New York State Smokers’ Quitline is free and confidential at 1-866-NY-QUITS.
Cigar and cigarillo questions
What is the difference between a cigar and a cigarillo?
Size: a cigarillo is shorter and narrower, so it takes a fraction of the time. Cigarillos are also more often machine-made, and premium cigars hand-rolled.
How long does a cigarillo take compared to a cigar?
A cigarillo takes minutes. A full-size premium cigar takes most of an hour, depending on the vitola.
Are cigarillos cheaper than cigars?
On our shelf, yes, by a wide margin at the entry end. Both ranges are published on the cigar page.
Which should I try first if I have never smoked either?
Ask at the counter, and think about how much time you want to spend. Singles let one stick settle the question before a box does.